35 Good Reasons Not to Circumcise:
"I always see more problems from a circumcision than from a foreskin."
- a paediatrician, quoted on America On Line.
1 |
Infection and sometimes death |
2 |
Haemorrhage and sometimes death |
3 |
Pain / shock, and sometimes death |
4 |
Meth[a]emoglobin[a]emia, brain damage and possibly death, if EMLA cream is used to anaesthetise a newborn |
5 |
|
6 |
Damage (scarring, pitting) to the glans or shaft. In the case of Dustin Evans Jr, the scarring caused a urethral stricture (narrowing of the urinary tube), and it was during an operation to relieve this that he died. |
7 |
Urethral fissure/fistula |
8 |
Scaphoid megalourethra |
9 |
"Trapped/buried penis" |
10 |
Occlusion of penile venous system |
11 |
Urinary Tract Infection |
12 |
Meatitis |
13 |
Meatal ulcer |
14 |
Meatal stenosis |
15 |
Multiple pyogenic granuloma - a series of papillomatous (brushlike) growths around the circumcision wound (Pyogenic means "caused by pus") |
16 |
Eczema of the glans and meatus |
17 |
Oedema of local tissue |
18 |
Loss of sensitivity / impotence |
19 |
Reduced volume of penis |
20 |
May shorten the penis: |
21 |
Painful erections |
22 |
Wound re-opening (in adulthood) |
23 |
Production of ugly scar tissue, skin-bridges, skin-tags, malapposition (rejoining on the twist) and/or suture holes |
24 |
Breach of bodily integrity |
25 |
Breach of human rights |
26 |
Breach of property rights |
27 |
Psychological trauma, resulting in eg. elective muteness |
28 |
Because he had had enough of a struggle just to be born, and deserved no more pain |
29 |
Loss of an organ for stimulating the partner and retaining semen in the vagina after ejaculation |
30 |
Loss of an organ for play, docking, etc. |
31 |
Loss of skin for plastic surgery of hypospadias |
32 |
Loss of skin for plastic surgery to eyelids |
33 |
Loss of protection against frostbite. |
34 |
Because the foreskin evolved over tens of millions of years and every male mammal has one. / Because God knew what S/He was doing when S/He put it there. / Because Nature knows best. |
35 |
Because he will almost always be glad you didn't |
36 |
Cost (That's why Elvis was intact.) |
Eight Debatable Reasons Not to Circumcise:
1 |
SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome - cot death) |
2 |
Because circumcision hinders the establishment of breast-feeding |
3 |
Increased risk of HIV |
4 |
Prostate cancer, due to reduced innervation impairing prostate function on ejaculation |
5 |
Impotence |
6 |
Because balanitis may indicate diabetes |
7 |
Because condoms slip off circumcised penes more easily. |
8 |
Because he might be switched with another baby being circumcised at the same time (Memphis, TN, 16/4/98 (AP)) |
See also the lists of Functions of the Foreskin and Circumstitions.
Go back to the Intactivism index page